Cutcher | Insights and News

Understanding insurance with real-life case studies.

Written by Andrew Harrison, Director, General Insurance | 12 February 2025 3:32:43 AM

Insurance is an essential safety net for your business, helping you handle unexpected financial setbacks. No matter what comes your way, the right coverage can make all the difference in managing risks. In this article, we’ll look at real-life case studies that show how different types of insurance can step in and save the day when businesses need it most. 

Management liability: Breach of director’s duties 

Background 

A medical practice, generating under $10 million annually, faced a crippling lawsuit. A director and shareholder demanded the business buy back $2 million in shares – or face complete shutdown. 

Outcome 

The practice won in court, but the legal battle cost a staggering $460,000. Fortunately, their Directors and Officers Liability insurance covered every penny. This case underscores the devastating financial impact of internal disputes and the critical protection offered by management liability coverage. 

Cyber Insurance: Ransomware Attack on Medical Services 

Background 

A medical service provider with six staff and a turnover of $3.2 million suffered a serious cybersecurity incident. A ransomware attack compromised their system, which held confidential patient data. Because of this, the business was unable to operate, leading to potential reputational and financial damage. 

Outcome 

The business’s cyber insurance policy kicked in, and an IT forensic expert assessed and fixed the system, as well as investigated if the hacker still had access. Legal experts also stepped in to figure out if they needed to notify regulatory bodies, such as the Privacy Commissioner. 

The policy covered costs for business downtime, forensic investigations, and legal fees, with a total payout of $63,000. This case is a reminder that cyber threats are on the rise and why having cyber insurance is crucial for businesses handling sensitive data. 

Business Insurance: Property Damage and Business Interruption 

Background 

Imagine the chaos: A quiet GP clinic, eight staff bustling about, $2.2 million annual revenue ticking along. Suddenly, an elderly patient, foot slipping, hits the accelerator instead of the brake. The car slams into the building, shattering an external wall and wrecking a treatment room, plumbing and all. 

Outcome 

The clinic's property damage claim was quickly assessed, and the insurer agreed to cover the repair costs. But the damage went beyond bricks and mortar. With a treatment room out of commission, revenue plummeted.  

Fortunately, their business interruption insurance kicked in, compensating them for the lost income. This near-disaster highlights why comprehensive business insurance is crucial – it's not just about the building; it's about protecting your entire livelihood. 

These real-life examples show just how many risks businesses can run into and why having the right insurance is so important. If you own a business, it’s worth taking a look at your policies to make sure you’re covered. 

Do you need personalised advice? Get in touch with us today.